牛翠波

• 1:华南师范大学政治与行政学院

摘要(Abstract)：

从事刑事诉讼的人员可能会冒"证实偏向"或"隧道观点"的风险,即可能坚信犯罪嫌疑人有罪,而对其事实上是无辜的这一替代方案充耳不闻。这可能体现在进行有罪证实调查情况的偏好上,甚至反对旨在证实替代方案的调查活动。研究结果显示,额外调查证据的收集方向是通过对嫌疑人罪行的初步评估来确定的;参与者倾向于选择通过增加有罪调查来增加罪行的严重程度,并与目前案件卷宗中所掌握的证据有力程度有关;罪证调查的选择与定罪比率有关。

关键词(KeyWords)： 刑事侦查;证据认定;证实偏向;隧道观点;决策

Abstract:

Keywords:

基金项目(Foundation):

作者(Author): 牛翠波

DOI: 10.16452/j.cnki.sdkjsk.2013.03.009

参考文献(References)：

• [1]KASSIN S M.On the psychology of confessions:does innocence put innocents at risk?[J].American Psychologist,2005(60):21.
• [2]NICKERSON R S.Confirmation bias:a ubiquitous phenomenon in many guises[J].Review of General Psychology,1998(2):175.
• [3]LORD C G,ROSS L,LEPPER M R.Biased assimilation and attitude polarization:the effects of prior theories on subsequent-ly considered evidence[J].Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,1979(37):2098-2109.
• [4]WASON P C.Reasoning about a rule[J].Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology,1968(20):273-281.
• [5]张志强.湖北京山杀妻错案当事人服刑11年后无罪释放[EB/OL].(2005-04-02).http://news.sina.com.cn/s/2005-04-02/03086262295.shtml.
• [6]DROR I E,CHALTON D,PERON A E.Contextual information renders experts vulnerable to making erroneous identifica-tions[J].Forensic Science International,2006(156):74-78.
• [7]FINDLEY K A,SCOTT M S.The multiple dimensions of tunnel vision in criminal cases[M].Wisconsin Law Review,2006(2):291-397.
• [8]MEISSNER C A,KASSIN S M.‘He’s guilty!’investigator bias in judgments of truth and deception[J].Law and Human Behavior,2002(26):469-480.
• [9]CARLSON K A,RUSSO J E.Biased interpretation of evidence by mock jurors[J].Journal of Experimental Psychology:Ap-plied,2001(7):91-103.
• [10]SNYDER M,SWANN W B.Hypothesis-testing processes in social interaction[J].Journal of Personality and Social Psy-chology,1978(36):1202-1212.
• [11]NICKERSON R S.Confirmation bias:a ubiquitous phenomenon in many guises[J].Review of General Psychology,1998(2):175-220.
• [12]DE KEIJSER J W,VAN KOPPEN P J.Paradoxes of proof and punishment:psychological pitfalls in judicial decision mak-ing[J].Legal and Criminological Psychology,2007(12):189-205.
• [13]BRIGHT D A,GOODMAN-DELAHUNTY J.The influence of gruesome verbal evidence on mock juror verdicts.Psychia-try[J].Psychology and Law,2004(11):154-166.
• [14]DROR I E,PERON A E,et al.When emotions get the better of us:the effect of contextual top-down processing on matc-hing fingerprints[J].Applied Cognitive Psychology,2005(19):799-809.
• [15]POSTHUMUS F.Evaluatieonderzoek in de Schiedammer parkmoord[Evaluation in the Schiedam park murder][M].Den Haag:Openbaar ministerie,2005:342-365.
• [16]INBAU F E,REID J.E,et al.Criminal interrogation and confessions[M].Gaithersburg:Aspen Publishers,2001:85-88.
• [17]KALVEN H,ZEISEL H.The American jury[M].Boston:Little brown,1966:78-82.
• [18]RASSIN E.Blindness to alternative scenarios in evidence evaluation.[J].Journal of Investigative Psychology and Offender Profiling,2010(7):153-163.
• [19]JONAS E,SCHULZ-HARDT S,FREY D,THELEN N.Confirmation bias in sequential information search after prelimina-ry decisions:an expansion of dissonance theoretical research on selective exposure to information[J].Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,2001(80):557-571.
• [20]KERSTHOLT J H,EIKELBOOM A R.Effects of prior interpretation on situation assessment in crime analysis[J].Journal of Behavioral Decision Making,2007(20):455-465.
• [21]SCHUNEMANN B,BANDILLA W.Perseverance in courtroom decisions.In H.Wegener,F.Losel,&J.Haisch(Eds.),Criminal behavior and the justice system:psychological perspectives[M].New York:Springer,1989:181-192.
• [22]SNOOK B,CULLEN R M.Bounded rationality and criminal investigations:has tunnel vision been wrongfully convicted?In D.K.Rossmo(Ed.),Criminal investigative failures[M].Boca Raton:CRC press,Taylor&Francis Group,2008:71-98.
• [23]JENKINS G,SCHULLER R A.The impact of negative forensic evidence on mock juror’s perceptions of a trial of drug-fa-cilitated sexual assault[J].Law and Human Behavior,2007(31):369-380.
• [24]MCKENZIE C R M,LEE S M,CHEN K K.When negative evidence increases confidence:change in belief after hearing two sides of a dispute[J].Journal of Behavioral Decision Making,2002(15):1-18.
• [25]JERVIS R.Reports,politics,and intelligence failures:the case of Iraq[J].The Journal of Strategic Studies,2006(29):3-52.